The next source of inspiration in the MELO Round 1 was Gollum's Song. Here are some of the best, IMO.
Tim W. built Gollum's Cave. This was my favorite of these and easily advanced to round 2.
My second favorite was Graeme Straughn's To Catch A Fish... So Juicy Sweetttt!!. This illustration of the scene from the Two Towers also easily advanced.
I'm not sure where exactly Bane of Seagulls' End of the Road is set--presumably when Sam and Frodo first meet Gollum at the edge of the Emyn Muil. This also advanced.
Theomatic's Forbidden Pool was a nice entry, though it did not advance.
Finally, Pieter Dennison had a very different take. Rather than illustrate a scene from Gollum's life, some of the lyrics in the song made him think of the story line of the video game Middle Earth; Shadow of Mordor. His unique take, You are banished from death.. was one of the top scoring entries in round 1, moving on into round 2.